A ‘one injection’ cure for Arthritis within five years … well, let’s hope so!

August 15, 2008 at 1:02 pm | Posted in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) | 5 Comments
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Some great news was widely reported yesterday – there might be a cure for rheumatoid arthritis and it could be tested and available within five years. No disputing it, that is great news! But a word or two of caution …

Unlike a drug, this treatment involves taking cells from a patient’s immune system, altering them in the lab and injection them back in to a joint affected by rheumatoid arthritis. However, not only have there been no human trials yet, there have actually been no trials at all. The only work that’s been done so far is on the cells in the laboratory.

The announcement seems a little premature to me because they don’t even know yet whether the re-injection of the cells will cause the ‘fixed’ immune system cells to spread through the body or not.

The injection is likely to cost in the region of £25,000 according to press reports. The cynic in me wonders whether that’s why it’s being billed as a ‘one injection cure’. Because if all it did was halt the disease in one joint, and most RA patients have many joints affected, the cost would be totally prohibitive and perhaps the research would be stopped. According to the Daily Telegraph : ‘The team also hope to find out if the vaccine is effective only in the joints it is injected into, or whether the new cells spread throughout the body.’ So as yet they really have no idea whether it’s a cure or something to help one badly affected joint. And if it affects one joint for £25,000, the ‘National Institute for Clinical Excellence,’ in the UK, (who are the folks that decide whether medication is too expensive to give to patients, and who are often known as NASTY for obvious acronym reasons) certainly won’t be letting us UK folk have this on the NHS!

The BBC’s report quotes Professor Alan Silman, from the Arthritis Research Campaign, who are a charity I hold in great esteem and who are funding this research, as saying that the cells should be ‘reset’ to normal activity, rather than attacking the joints and that ‘The presumption is that they will stay this way, unless the same trigger which is thought to cause the problem in the first place is encountered again. Aye, there’s the rub!!

Not only is this currently nothing more than a presumption, but more importantly we don’t actually know what the trigger is – or I should probably say what the triggers are, as it’s thought that there are many different triggers. So let’s suppose, as has been suggested in the scientific literature, that one of the many triggers is consumption of decaffeinated coffee. If the cell ‘resetting’ is a success and NASTY decides the treatment will be made available an the NHS, then I toddle off for my injection, it works, I feel fantastic for a day or two (and that’s assuming, of course, that it doesn’t have some horrible side effects) and then I have a nice cup of decaffeinated coffee … if that’s my trigger, Wham – flare up – back to square one? I don’t know, but maybe. There isn’t even a comprehensive list of known triggers, so it’s not possible to even avoid them after the injection!

Then there’s the side effect thing – this is, like the current DMARDS and anti-TNFs, something that affects the immune system, stopping it from attacking the joints in error. Again according to the Telegraph article, and they may have got the wrong end of the stick slightly, or I may have, and I haven’t read any scientific paper on this, ‘Using chemicals, steroids and Vitamin D, the team has devised a way to manipulate a patient’s white blood cells so they suppress, rather than activate, the immune system.’ So …where does the immune system go? Is one cured of RA but suddenly unable to leave a big plastic bubble for fear of getting a common cold and dying from it due to lack of immune system? Probably not, because it’s probably very specific cells they’re targeting, but I’d like to understand this a bit better.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m delighted that RA, and cures for it, are being thoroughly researched, and even more glad that there might be a light at the end of the tunnel. As someone said on the NRAS forum yesterday, hope is a good medicine in itself. I’d just have appreciated some slightly more balanced and less gungho reporting.

5 Comments »

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. Dear Pollyanna (I know, not your real name)

    I worked part time for a site called Patient Opinion – in case you haven’t come across it, it collects patients stories and uses them to help NHS organisations improve their service and care for patients.

    As someone living with a long term condition, the experiences you have of the NHS are of enormous value and can really help to improve the service you received from the NHS. If you are interested and would like to share your stories, good or bad, or the NHS, we can make sure the right people here them.

    I’ve really enjoyed reading your blog. Thank you

    Helen for

  2. Accidentally deleted Helen’s follow up email with the correct web address! It is http://www.patientopinion.org.uk

    Thanks for the update Helen, and sorry I deleted it!

    PP

  3. Agreed. Hope is our best answer and research is critical to attacking RA as soon as possible. Side effects always seem to crop up when dealing with drugs and I sure hope they could find a natural treatment for arthritis. Let’s keep our fingers crossed so more of us can live a pain free life.

    Bob
    Healthy Arthritis Treatments

  4. [...] Bextra and Vioxx — Tips for Arthritis Relief Without Them Saved by ange1e on Mon 22-12-2008 A ‘one injection’ cure for Arthritis within five years … well, let … Saved by tenshi79 on Thu 18-12-2008 Aquatic Therapy for Arthritis Saved by filtrogigi on Mon [...]

  5. cat sneezing constantly

    A ‘one injection’ cure for Arthritis within five years … well, let’s hope so! | Pollyanna Penguin’s RA Blog


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com. | The Pool Theme.
Entries and comments feeds.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 89 other followers

%d bloggers like this: